Paul Watson (documentary filmmaker)

On presenting Watson with the 2008 BAFTA Special Award for Outstanding Creative Contribution to the industry, John Wills described him as "...one of the giants of documentary film-making. Over several decades he has created a string of memorable and often controversial documentaries, always striving for innovation in both form and content and invariably succeeding. He is a very well deserved winner of this prestigious BAFTA Special Award".

Malcolm and Barbara: Love’s Farewell (ITV, 2007), which follows the progression of Alzheimer disease in a middle-aged man (Malcolm Pointon) and its impact on his marriage, created the most controversial moment in Watson’s career. Controversy arose when a press statement released ahead of broadcast stated that the programme included footage of Malcolm Pointon’s death. This triggered questions in the press about the ethics of filming death for a television programme. Events took an unexpected turn when it transpired that the sequence purportedly showing the death of Malcom Pointon, in fact, did not. This came to light in a statement made by Graham Pointon (the brother of Malcolm) that Malcolm died two and a half days after filming had concluded. This catapulted the programme into the wider controversy over media fakery, such as the recent discovery that the BBC  had faked phone-ins on Comic Relief, Children in Need and Sport Relief. After some tense, behind-the-scenes negotiations between Watson and ITV, both parties acknowledged publicly that the programme did not feature Malcolm Pointon’s actual death. The film was broadcast with an extra line of commentary clarifying the final scene. The controversy continued to build when ITV launched a formal inquiry into the matter which blamed Watson for the misunderstanding, although it conceded that Watson had not acted with any deliberate intention to mislead. Watson, in response, said that he felt he had been "hung out to dry"  by ITV. Barbara, Malcolm Pointon’s widow, defended Watson, stating that "Paul filmed Malcolm's last semi-conscious moments - and those were the most precious to me, because after that he just drifted into a coma and faded away...The film ends with a freeze frame, a still image, which very simply, very sensitively, and very poignantly sends the message Malcolm has died...end of story…Does it really matter whether it was two minutes, two days, or two weeks after that point? It doesn't alter the fact Malcolm died of this illness…And that's the message I wanted to get through - that Alzheimer's kills”. There was support for Watson among media commentators, one arguing that while his mistake had been in “allowing an ambiguity to develop before transmission…it's not as if he tricked the audience into spending millions voting on the moment of death”. The controversy surrounding the programme was deemed to have been unfortunate “since the film is a fine piece of work by a film maker of rare talent”.

Convictions (BBC, 1998), broadcast under the 40 Minutes strand, was banned. [corroboration required].

The Dinner Party (Channel 4, 1997), broadcast under the Cutting Edge strand, is a film about eight friends, all wealthy British Conservatives, who come together for a dinner party in the lead up to Labour’s 1997 electoral victory. Described in Channel 4’s programme listings as capturing “the end of the 1979-1997 Conservative era through the opinions of a group of Home Counties dinner party guests”. Has been described as a “candid film (which) caused a stir because of the unpalatable views expressed by its subjects. Racism and homophobia were openly on display”. The controversy began before broadcast, as information about the programme circulated among the UK press. One journalist noted that, “Carefully orchestrated advance publicity makes the mood of the programme clear – the…(e)ight are shown as mad, stupid, bigoted members of a doomed middle England whose booze-addled brains are good for little more than fitful dreams of Margaret Thatcher”. The programme contributors claimed they had been "stitched up" by Watson, a view supported by some reviewers. Months after broadcast, Watson, at the Edinburgh International Television Festival, defended the film, saying "They knew they had said what they had said…One had said, 'Shoot the bastards', referring to immigrants and it had gone in the film". Watson denied the guests had been exploited while drunk, adding: "Some of the most excessive forms of expression were said sober". Channel 4 acknowledged that it had timed its broadcast to cause embarrassment to the Government just before the 1997 general election.

"Anyone Googling Paul Watson will soon read that he is credited with creating reality TV. His 1993 series Sylvania Waters is widely regarded as the first reality show in TV history, just as his 1974 series, The Family, invented the fly-on-the-wall serial. "People say you're the godfather of reality television," he scoffs. "Who'd want to be a godfather to such bastards?".

Sylvania Waters (BBC One/ABC, 1992) is a documentary series about the domestic life of an Australian family from Sylvania Waters, a well-off Sydney suburb. Noeline, described as the “loud-mouthed matriarch of the nouveau riche Baker-Donaher family” claimed that she was scorned when the programme was shown in Australia. "They told us our address wouldn't be used, then the name was changed from The Family to Sylvania Waters and we had helicopters above our home and reporters all over our garden".  ''Only last week I was verbally attacked by a group of hooligans outside my house”. There was further controversy in 1993, when Noeline appeared at the Edinburgh International Television Festival and took part in a face-to-face conversation with the programmes Directors Brian Hills and Kate Wood. [Watson was the programme producer.] She told the audience of television professionals that, "I've cried, I've wept, I've wailed, I've screamed…and I'd like to put my hands around the producer Paul Watson’s neck”, adding that she had been driven to the verge of suicide. After hearing of Watson's difficulties at the BBC, she reportedly said ''I'm glad that he's hit rock bottom. What he did to me was character assassination. He made me a monster''. Watson’s response to Noeline’s remarks was,  "Bollocks…I left her with an agent, a manager and an accountant because she was becoming famous, and it was the only way they could think of to make money. In the end she asked me to make another series. She hugs me now".

From the late 1990s, Watson started shooting his own films, either partially or completely. In 2006, he stated that he'd “held the camera for my last six or seven films…It's so liberating…Camera crews are great for dramas and they play with the f-stop brilliantly, but they don't see your point of view. So I get access but worse picture quality”. Films in this category include:

The Fishing Party (BBC Two, 1985), broadcast as part of the 40 Minutes strand, was a documentary about four friends, all rich young city commodity-brokers, who go on a fishing holiday in Scotland to see if they can break the world record for a catch of skate.  The film was pitched as capturing the mood of the Thatcher years and the contributors were as representative of “rabid Thatcherism”. One of the contributors was later fined £650 for shooting at a seagull.  In 2006, the contributors reputedly hijacked an appearance by Watson at the 2006 Sheffield Doc Fest and accused him of ruining their lives [further corroboration required]. Watson's defence of The Fishing Party was that he did not “‘stitch them up’. Quite the reverse, I open(ed) them up. In order to do that I have to manipulate. That is done only in the cutting room, not on location. The process is called editing. By juxtaposing scenes and statements that I consider to be relevant, certain truths become evident". The programme has been labelled as “Thatcher's least favourite film (because) ”it galvanised distaste for the Tory Government”. It later transpired that the programme had been 'referred upwards' to senior management because of queasiness about its depiction of four extreme right-wing apologists.

The Family (BBC One, 1974), a documentary series about the Wilkins family from Reading, created controversy when it was shown in 1974. Watson has stated that, "Back then, working-class people weren't directly presented on TV…You'd have experts standing in front of them; the great and the good referring to 'these people’". When he created The Family, Watson has said, “I had an agenda…I wanted to put a working-class family on television because it had not been done and they had much to tell”. The programme created an immediate stir. “Many viewers were genuinely shocked at the way ordinary people could open up their most intimate - though usually minor - secrets to the public gaze”. During the broadcast of the series, Watson reported that “We had lots of obnoxious letters from the middle classes saying how dare you show these people…here were the Wilkins, with a love child, living in overcrowded conditions, teaching their children to fib to the council about getting housing points. These things had never been discussed on a popular mainstream channel like BBC1". A year or so after the broadcast, the Wilkinses’ marriage broke up. Watson said, “I was accused of wrecking a family…But they [the couple] said, ‘Paul, look, we have just watched ourselves for 12 weeks and we can see perfectly easily that we are just chalk and cheese together.’ I put a big mirror in front of them”.

Born on 17 February 1942 in Paddington, London and grew up in Wood Green. Family moved to Bolton, Lancashire after father obtained work in the textile mills. Attended Altrincham Grammar School, Cheshire. Attained A Level Art aged 16. Attended Manchester Regional College of Art, then Royal College of Art, London 1963-1966. Started working for the BBC in the mid-1960s, first job as researcher on Whicker's World. Given own documentary series A Year in the Life, followed by singles for the Tuesday's Documentary strand. In 1974, made The Family, one of his most well known programmes. In the following decade, worked with Egyptologist John Romer and made singles for Real Lives and 40 Minutes strands, including The Fishing Party in 1985. In 1987, undertook secondment at WGBH in Boston. From 1989, headed a production unit at BBC Elstree where he instigated Sylvania Waters. At Elstree, he worked primarily as Executive producer on series such as Present Imperfect. 1993-1994, he was appointed Series Editor of 40 Minutes. Left the BBC in 1994. From 1995, worked for Granada TV, making singles for the Cutting Edge strand and the first of two films about Malcolm Pointon and his diagnosis with Alzheimer's (Malcolm and Barbara: A Love Story). From 1999/2000, headed documentary production at United Productions (part of United News and Media, in collaboration with Anglia, HTV and Meridian; United Productions taken over by Granada Media in 2000). Left United Productions in 2002. In 2002, formed his own production company Priory Pictures, making one of his most acclaimed films Rain In My Heart. In 2007, the second of two films about Malcolm Pointon and his Alzheimer's disease was broadcast (Malcolm and Barbara: Loves Farewell). In 2009-2010, he returned to media work, writing and directing radio plays for BBC Radio 4. He lives in Tonbridge, Kent.