Roma Rothstein

After the war, Blumenthal went to Warsaw with the hope of finding her remaining family members who had not been in the Warsaw Ghetto. Blumenthal was able to make contact with Rothstein's father. He had survived by leaving the Warsaw Ghetto and moving to Tel-Aviv. He managed to get Rothstein Blumenthal sent to Paris until 1947, when Samuel Rothstein was able to get visas for Rothstein and Blumenthal to join him in Tel-Aviv. While in Paris, Rothstein met Shlomo Roth, who she later married. Soon after her marriage, she and her husband emigrated to the United States, where they have five children. After the war, Rothstein published the book, "Here There Is No Why," an autobiography of her life and her time in the concentration camps.

In November 1944, Blumenthal and Rothstein were moved to the Bergen-Belsen concentration camp. They remained here until the British Army liberated the camp on April 15, 1945.

From 1943 to 1945, Rothstein stayed in three concentration camps: Majdanek, Auschwitz, and Bergen-Belsen. In Majdanek, Blumenthal's father, along with most of the other older prisoners, was sent to the gas chambers. Blumenthal and Rothstein were also sent to the gas chambers, but by chance there were 700 women in the gas chamber when the "quota" was 500. Because of this, 200 women were removed from the gas chamber. Blumenthal and Rothstein were two of the lucky ones to be removed. As Blumenthal said in a testimony:

In July 1943, Blumenthal and Rothenstein were moved to Auschwitz. At Auschwitz, Rothstein and Blumenthal were shaved and tattooed with numbers. Rothstein's number was 48915. Rothstein contracted typhus in Auschwitz and was moved to a camp hospital. On the third day of her being there, the doctor warned her that all remaining patients would be gassed. Unable to walk, Rothstein crawled out of the hospital and survived. At one point, Rothstein asked Blumenthal if she would commit suicide with her by touching the electrically charged barbed wire fence. Blumenthal refused, as she still wished to live.

Ruchama Rachel Rothstein (born 2 June 1926) is a Holocaust survivor and the author of "Here there is no Why". Her aunt Ella Blumenthal and she were the only members of their immediate family to survive the Holocaust.

Rothstein was born on 2 June 1926 to Golda and Samuel Rothstein. Her mother owned a men's clothing shop, while her father was a Rabbi and journalist editor of the Yiddishe Tugblatt. Roma was the oldest of four children. She had a happy childhood until the Nazi invasion of Poland in 1939, when she was 13. After the invasion, Rothstein and her family were moved into the Warsaw Ghetto. Rothstein stayed there until the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising. Rothstein participated in the uprising by smuggling weapons around the ghetto. After the uprising failed, Rothstein, her aunt Ella Blumenthal, and Blumenthal's father were transferred to the Majdanek and Treblinka death camps, along with the rest of the surviving Warsaw Ghetto residents.