William Lewis Reece

Following his conviction for Johnson's murder in Oklahoma, Reece was extradited to stand trial in Texas in early March 2022. He pleaded guilty to all three murders and was sentenced to life imprisonment in June 2022.

On August 19, 2021, Reece was officially sentenced to death by the Oklahoma County District Court. After the trial, prosecutors stated that their client had given partially false information in his confession and failed to disclose both his true motives for the crime and the accurate details. Two days before his conviction, he was charged with possessing prohibited items after a search of his cell at the county jail revealed that he had purchased a cell phone from fellow inmates.

The trial began on April 21, 2017. Reece's defense team filed a motion for a change of venue, claiming that the county courthouse offices contained asbestos dust that could negatively affect the health of the trial's participants. An independent examination concluded that the building's condition was hazardous. The trial adjourned until June 2019. In the meantime, prosecutors from Texas announced that they would extradite him to their state to stand trial for the murders of Smither, Cox, and Cain after the end of his Oklahoma trial.

In early 2016, Reece began cooperating with investigators, admitted responsibility for the Johnston murder, and further confessed to three murders in Houston during the summer of 1997. With the help of his attorneys, he contacted the prosecutor's offices in Brazoria and Harris Counties, and provided a map of the burial sites. He then offered to admit fully to the crimes in court to avoid the death penalty and guarantee he would serve his sentence in Oklahoma. Authorities refused the deal, excavated the burial sites indicated on the map, and discovered the skeletal remains of Kelli Ann Cox and Jessica Cain.

In July 2016, Reece was extradited from Texas to Oklahoma to stand trial for the murder of Johnston. A few days later, he appeared before the Oklahoma County District Court, where a hearing was scheduled for October 10, 2016, after he waived his right to a speedy trial.

After his conviction for kidnapping and rape, Reece was transferred to the Ellis Unit to serve his sentence. In the early 2000s, he was compelled by law to submit DNA samples to be entered into CODIS.

Reece was convicted of the kidnapping charged in 1998 and sentenced to 60 years imprisonment.

After his release, Reece moved into his mother's home in Anadarko, Oklahoma. In early 1997, he regained his driver's license and moved to Houston, Texas.

In the fall of 1997, Reece became a suspect in the kidnapping and attempted rape of 19-year-old Sandra Sapaugh. According to her testimony, in May 1997, Sapaugh stopped her car at a gas station in Webster to use a pay phone, where she was spotted by Reece. She got into her car and began to drive, but after a few minutes she realized that one of her tires was flat and was forced to stop. Reece, trailing behind her in his white truck, stopped and offered to help her.

In 2015, his DNA was matched to the murder of 19-year-old Tiffany Johnston. On July 26, 1997, Johnston's Dodge Neon was found abandoned at the Sunshine Car Wash in Bethany, Oklahoma. The owner of the Sunshine Car Wash told police that Reece frequently used the car wash. Johnston's body was later found on the side of a dirt road near the I-40. Johnston had been sexually assaulted, beaten and strangled. On September 21, 2015, Reece was formally charged with her murder.

Reece stated that he committed his first murder on April 3, 1997, when he killed 12-year-old Laura Smither in Friendswood. According to Reese, he accidentally hit Smither with his car on a rainy day. He admitted to hiding Smither's body in a lake. Later, Reece admitted to strangling the girl to death.

Reece also confessed that on July 15, 1997, he was driving from Oklahoma to Houston when he stopped to buy some whiskey at a gas station in Denton. He claimed that he got into a physical confrontation with 20-year-old Kelli Cox, a student at the University of North Texas and strangled her in the ensuing fight. Cox was found buried in the woods in Brazoria County. Like with the Smither case, he insisted that Cox had not been sexually assaulted.

According to Reece's account, on July 26, 1997, he stopped at the Sunshine Car Wash in Bethany to clean his truck and accidentally sprayed Tiffany Johnston. Without witnesses, he grabbed the teenager and dragged her inside the trailer, where he raped her at gunpoint. Reece Johnson struck her over the head with a horseshoe and attacked her. He admitted strangling her and putting her body in the woods by the side of a road, where it was discovered the following day. Reece stated that he knew Johnson's mother, Kathy Dobry, who lived in Anadarko and was an acquaintance of his mother and other members of his family.

17-year-old Jessica Cain was reported missing on August 17, 1997. She was last seen alive after leaving a Bennigan's in the Clear Lake suburb, and her car was abandoned on an interstate highway later that day. Reece claimed he had approached her outside the restaurant, but she rebuffed him. Angered, he tailed her vehicle until she was forced to stop and confront him. He admitted that he beat and strangled her.

The trial was indefinitely postponed due to the COVID-19 pandemic and resumed in May 2021. Among the people present at the trial were Tiffany Johnston's relatives, law enforcement officers involved in the murder investigation, Sandra Sapaugh, and two other girls who claimed that Reece had kidnapped and raped them in the Houston area on July 3, 1997. On May 28, he was found guilty on all counts by jury verdict. His defense attorney had advocated for an acquittal based on the supposedly broken plea agreement between his client and law enforcement officials.

While at large, a month after his release, he sexually assaulted another woman and was re-arrested. He was put on trial for both rapes, found guilty, and sentenced to 25 years imprisonment. His attorneys appealed the conviction to a criminal court, which granted a review of his case. The results indicated that there were procedural errors in Reece's criminal case, causing his sentence to be reduced and leading to his parole in October 1996.

In April 1986, Reece kidnapped the 19-year-old daughter of a sheriff's deputy. The woman was driving to a local gym when her car stalled. Reece, who worked as a truck driver at the time, lured her into his truck with the promise of taking her to the nearest payphone. Instead, he tied the woman up and raped her. Reece then drove the victim to a nearby motel, where he rented a room for the night. He allowed her to use the bathroom, giving her an opportunity to escape and call the police. Reece was arrested and charged but was released from custody after paying his bail.

After their marriage, Reece enlisted in the Oklahoma National Guard, but left after some time. His wife divorced him a year into their marriage. Reece convinced her to remarry him, and the couple had a second child shortly afterward. Flaming said Reese began drinking heavily and being physically abusive. In 1982, Flaming went to the police after a beating and said that her husband had threatened to kill her with a knife and shotgun. She divorced him.

William Lewis Reece (born July 1, 1959) is an American serial killer, rapist and kidnapper. In 2015, he was linked via DNA to the 1997 cold case murder of a girl in Oklahoma, for which he was subsequently convicted and sentenced to death. Not long after, he confessed to three murders associated with the Texas Killing Fields, for which he was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment in 2022.

William Lewis Reece was born on July 1, 1959, in Oklahoma, one of 13 siblings. He spent his youth in the cities of Yukon and Anadarko. Due to his parents' financial issues, he was forced to quit school after the ninth grade and take on a job as a farm laborer. In 1979, he married Judy Flaming after she became pregnant.