William Wickline

For the remainder of his life behind bars, Wickline unsuccessfully appealed to both state and federal courts, all of which rejected his appeals. After exhausting all of his appeals, Wickline was executed via lethal injection at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility on March 30, 2004. His final meal consisted of an eight-ounce medium-rare filet mignon, old-fashioned potato salad, six buttered rolls, fresh strawberries, shortcake and butter pecan ice cream. After entering the execution chamber, he gave two thumbs up to his brothers, who were attending, and calmly awaited the process to take place. His supposed last words were "May tomorrow see the courts shaped by more wisdom and less politics."

Shortly after the Lerches' disappearances, Wickline was arrested for breaking into a drug store in Nelsonville, for which he was given a year and a half sentence at the Pickaway Correctional Institution in Orient. Almost two years later, in December 1984, he was indicted in the Lerch case after Kemp confessed the crime to the authorities. Before he could even be officially charged, Wickline was additionally linked to the Marsh murder in West Virginia, and was proposed as a suspect in several other violent crimes involving dismemberment. However, he was nonetheless tried solely for the Lerches' murders, which began on July 30, 1985. A little more than a week later, he was found guilty on two counts of aggravated murder. On September 20, he was sentenced to death for Peggy's murder and to life imprisonment for Christopher's, to which he showed no emotion. While charges were filed in the Marsh murder, they were eventually dropped and the case closed due to Wickline's death sentence.

For a time, he was also proposed as an alternative suspect to the 1984 murders of Annette Cooper and Todd Schultz, for which Cooper's stepfather, Dale Johnston was convicted and sentenced to death, but whose guilt was questioned. In 2008, two other men confessed and were convicted of the crime, and Johnston was exonerated. In 2020, authorities identified Muncy's killer as Daniel Alan Anderson, a violent sex offender with past convictions for abusing young boys, who had died in 2013.

On August 14, 1982, Wickline and his girlfriend Teresa Kemp went to Columbus, Ohio to settle a $6,000 drug debt with Christopher and Peggy Lerch, a couple from Blendon Township who were involved in the drug trafficking business. After the argument, Wickline asked that Christopher accompany him to the upstairs bathroom, ostensibly to help him with a clogged tub drain, but while he was looking inside the tub, Wickline took out a knife and slit his throat. Deciding that he needed to get rid of Peggy as well, as she could be a potential witness, Wickline threatened to harm Kemp if she did not help him out by holding the sleeping woman's legs while he proceeded to strangle her to death with a rope. After killing both of the Lerches, Wickline transported their bodies to the bath tub, where he decapitated and dismembered their remains, which he then placed in plastic garbage bags. Afterwards, with Kemp's help, the pair dumped them in various garbage containers across Franklin County. As a sort of souvenir, Wickline kept Peggy's wedding ring. The Lerches' remains have never been located.

On November 11, 1979, the body of a 34-year-old construction worker from Columbia, South Carolina, Charles Morgan Marsh, was found on his bed at a hotel room in Parkersburg, West Virginia. Marsh's head had been decapitated and placed on the nightstand beside the bed, while his headless body had his hands handcuffed behind his back. Upon conducting the autopsy, coroners determined that the cause of death was strangulation with a telephone cord and that the murderer had severed the head with one or two cuts, indicating he was a skilled butcher. Most peculiarly, it was also determined that Marsh's killer had also taken his time to comb the hair of his victim's severed head. The violent nature of the crime and the fact that Marsh was a known drug dealer led investigators to believe that this was a likely contract killing, possibly by a rival dealer who wanted to prevent him from encroaching on his territory, but at the time, no suspect could be identified.

Wickline's first arrest came in 1971, at age 19, and until 1984, he would be arrested at least nine more times for charges ranging from burglary and dealing drugs to running a prostitution ring. During his incarcerations, he would spend much of his time doing pastimes such as lifting weights and studying psychology, and would integrate himself further within the prison system. After spending several years in different prisons around the state, Wickline would eventually be released yet again in November 1979, and after a temporary break-up with his girlfriend, he started displaying increasingly violent tendencies. During this period, he developed an affinity for knives and had numerous short-term relationships with various women, whom he verbally threatened on a few occasions. According to a friend of his, Wickline also allegedly participated in a group that conducted animal sacrifices and other violent activities, but this was never conclusively proven.

William Dean Wickline Jr. (March 15, 1952 – March 30, 2004), known as The Butcher, was an American career criminal and later serial killer linked to at least three violent murders committed in West Virginia and Ohio from 1979 to 1982. Convicted of killing the latter victims, whose bodies were never found, Wickline was sentenced to death and subsequently executed in 2004.

William Dean Wickline Jr. was born on March 15, 1952, in Reynoldsburg, Ohio, one of several sons born to William, Sr. and Irma Wickline (née Bolen). He grew up in what was described as a loving family, and during his youth, Wickline was regarded as a good student with a promising career in athletics. Despite these expectations and him being in his high school's wrestling team, Wickline's grades fell drastically and he became known as a small-time delinquent whose most egregious offense was egging his principal's car.